Jump to Navigation

Is retrograde extrapolation junk science?

 

Judges are supposed to be rigorous in determining the validity of evidence allowed in their courtrooms. Especially when it comes to scientific evidence, which most laypersons on a jury and the majority of judges are ill equipped to evaluate.

 

There are various standards, but ideally, the process should be accepted science, that is well understood and can be used to provide consistent results. Sadly, there are numerous incidents of poor science being used in courtrooms to obtain convictions. In what may be the most egregious example, one man was executed based on now generally discredited "junk science" that was used in an arson investigation. 

 

Another type of evidence that has been questioned, known as retrograde extrapolation has been used in many states as a method of guessing a person's blood alcohol content (BAC) levels at the time of an arrest or accident, when law enforcement only has available a measurement that was taken hours after the incident.

While it has some basis in science, there are a large number of variables in play when making the calculation. What the person was drinking, how much they drank, during what period, what they ate, their weight and the rate their body metabolizes alcohol, all of which can compromise the accuracy of any "extrapolation" that is based on averages and assumptions.

One DUI attorney notes that it is about as reliable as astrology, but prosecutors use it because many courts have permitted its use in the past and that habit provides some element of credibility that it otherwise might not have.

If you have been charged with a DUI in Minnesota, you should always challenge any testimony arguing the application of retrograde extrapolation. Because of the complexity of this determination, it may be possible to show the jury that such a determination is questionable, and not beyond a reasonable doubt.

Source: ap.org, "How drunk? Estimates questioned in drunken-driving cases," FRANK ELTMAN, October 4, 2015

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Contact us for a Free Consultation

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information
disclaimer.

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

close
Subscribe To This BLOG’S FEED visit our DWI DEFENSE website

Office Location

Sheridan & Dulas, P.A.
1380 Corporate Center Curve
Suite 320
Eagan, MN 55121
Phone: 651-968-1249
Toll Free: 800-491-9983
Fax: 651-686-7870
Map and Directions

FindLaw Network